Where I live, we have a very strong email list full of moms. Lots of local items are discussed like how to find a plumber or which restaurant to eat at. Sometimes conversations are deeper and even some get to the point of being heated. When I first moved to the island I started a support group called Families for natural living. This is a nation wide group based in Virginia. The name has since been changed to Families for Conscious Living. When I became a parent in England, this was my life line to sanity. All the strange things I was doing as a parent were not only respected by this group, but they were supported. Breastfeeding, organic diet, natural health, co-sleeping and so on. When we moved to Virginia, I couldn't wait to start my own group. This group became my community until we moved to the Seattle area. I quickly started one here but from the beginning it felt different. People didn't seem to need the support as much. And conversation just didn't flow like it did on our other FNL email list. Finally after five years of lack of participation I closed the group. I had recently written two very heart felt emails with no replies. This other island wide moms group moved to another venue and created a Green Parenting list. I thought it would be the perfect substitution for the FNL group. Maybe I'm just too honest and it scares people or maybe I say the wrong things? I wrote an email a month ago about co-sleeping and I only received one reply privately. Yesterday I was so moved by something that again I wrote to the group but only one person responded privately and defensively. Dh thinks my topic of choice was too delicate but I'm not sure. I tried to write it in the most gentle way. I'd love to hear your thoughts:
Here it is:
I picked up a book yesterday at the library on
AD/HD. I must say that although I've heard lots about this, I've yet to
ever read much about it. I think it's probably a good thing now that I
have read some of the check-lists in the book for your child possibly
being AD/HD. I was literally shocked to see that so many of the items
in the list applied not only to my daughter's personality but to mine
as well. It kind of made my stomach sick. Initially I was annoyed
because I don't need a label like this attached to myself in my 30's.
But then again, if I had been given this label when I was a kid, it
would have destroyed me.
I'm curious what people think of this
term AD/HD. Is it a positive view? Negative? Some of the things that
come up for me are giving kids medication and labeling them. Both of
these I think are somewhat negative. I don't know if they are near the
truth, they are just the first things that come to mind. Most of the
children I know that are my daughter's age might also fall into this
personality description but minus the label. I usually tend to hang out
with natural minded parents who seem to avoid Dr. visits more than the
rest of our culture.
Ironically I discovered an amazing book
this last summer called "Refuse to Choose" by Barbara Sher. I'm so
relieved I found this book before the AD/HD one. She talks about this
personality style.
She
calls people with this personality, scanners. I fit this description so
well. But her book is written in such a positive way that I finished
the book feeling so good that I am not alone. In fact that I'm just
hard wired different than the norm. And in fact that I am special. I
want to do everything and anything in life. She also mentions other
famous Scanners like Da Vinci.
Then I discussed her book on my
blog, and continue to do so and each time people write to me saying
that they never knew that there were others like them. They feel so
relieved to even know about having a word that describes their
personality. And that it is okay to be who they are.
Rudolf Steiner, the founder of Waldorf Education also has his own view on the Four Temperaments. From wiki:
"Waldorf
teachers use the concept of the four temperaments to help interpret,
understand and relate to the behaviour and personalities of children
under their tutelage. The temperaments, choleric, phlegmatic,
melancholic, and sanguine,[35] are thought to express four basic
personality types, each possessing its own fundamental way of regarding
and interacting with the world."
Both my daughter and I fit mostly into Choleric:
Walk: firm, heels dig into the ground with each step
Eyes: energetic, active
Relationships: friendly as long as he/she is in command
Food: spicy
Memory: poor
Interest: the world, self, and future
Clothing: individual and outstanding
To stimulate: issue a challenge
So
maybe labels are everywhere? And maybe it's up to us to figure out
whether they are positive or negative. And which to move forward on in
a helpful way.
I suppose if some people analyzed my daughter,
they might suggest that she should be medicated. She is a spirited
girl, full of life. I do find that when she has corn syrup and/or food
coloring her behavior can worsen. Same with when she is over stimulated
by tv/music/media. So on a daily basis we tend to avoid these.
Growing
up with style of personality I was teased nearly every day of my life,
my teachers shamed me a lot of the time for being eccentric/energetic
and from both of these I told myself that I would never to send my
child to a public school. Maybe things are different than when I grew
up or maybe it helps where I grew up (small farm town in Northern CA).
I just didn't want my own children to go through what I went
through. Last week I went to a meeting for next year's first grade
parents at the children's school. One thing that I mentioned in the meeting to the
other Kindergarten parents is the joy I have felt that my daughter's
spirit (she's in 3rd grade) is not only respected but she is given the
freedom to be who she is in a safe learning environment. I couldn't ask
for anything more as a parent. Every conference we have with my
daughter's teacher, she tells us how imaginative my daughter is and how
she throws her energy into her drawing and art.
I realize this
email is verging on babbling. I'm just trying to throw out some
thoughts on children and their personalities. Has your child been
labeled? How do you feel about it? Is this label really necessary? I'd
love to hear your thoughts on this.
************************************************************************
There you go. Was it too negative by my comments on medication? I mean the medication thing is my own belief. I haven't taken cold medication in probably 10 years because I feel that the natural route is more effective. I'm not trying to judge anyone that does take medication, it just doesn't fit into my family values. The one person who wrote me privately spoke very highly of medication and how it helped her child. One day the child couldn't read and within 6 weeks he could read. The child became social and happy. She also implied that AD/HD has a similar brain pattern to those who have been in a car accident. Hmmmm....I'm not sure what to think about that one.
I can't imagine medicating Cerys. While I would not miss her lows so much, I would miss her highs heartbreakingly so. The woman said the medication doesn't change her son, he's still the same boy. I just wanted to bring up that I can help my daughter with eliminating certain foods & media and honoring her spirit. I'll still refer to her as spirited because that is what she is to me. She's a little spitfire full of passion, beauty, emotion and spirit. I love her entirely for all of these and will work hard to keep her away from foods that bother her and media that overstimulates her.
Christmas- a couple years ago with her dad and uncle's knee.
So with all of that said, I miss my old parenting group where I could speak with my heart and have people who cared about what I said, reply. Of course many of you do that each time you read my blog and I am grateful for all of you. I would love to find an email list of natural parents that can fill the gap where my FNL list used to be. Do any of you have one to suggest? I hope onto the Mothering Boards from time to time but I'd love just an email list form. Thanks for listening to me and I don't mean any offense to anyone who does anything differently than me. I'm writing this from the angle of a naturally minded mama.